I love me some boots! I have been trying to wear boots in the brown family because they 'book end' my hair color so well. What I have discovered is that not all boots are equal with pants tucked in. You will see in the photo's above that proportion and where they cut your leg line is very important. To my eye the taller boots just look better. I tried to wear the same T shirt and jeans so it would be easier to compare these aren't finished looks just the underpinnings.